Monday, November 2, 2009

Supreme Court Decision on Identity Theft

By Laura Tillman, The Brownsville Herald

Immigrants who use false documents cannot be prosecuted for identity theft unless they know those documents belong to a real person, the Supreme Court ruled last week.

Local immigration attorneys called the ruling a "huge victory," saying government attorneys have frequently used the threat of an identity theft charge to intimidate undocumented immigrants into pleading guilty for lesser offenses. Identity theft carries a minimum sentence of two years.

"For the average undocumented immigrant who goes to the flea market and buys a social security card, how are they supposed to know if it belonged to a real person or not?" said Jodie Goodwin, a Harlingen-based lawyer who has been practicing immigration law for 14 years.

No comments:

Post a Comment